Home Blog Page 31

What Should a Financial Planner Actually Charge? The Fee-Value Equation Explained

Hemant Beniwal
-
15
What Should a Financial Planner Actually Charge? The Fee-Value Equation Explained

“Price is what you pay. Value is what you get.” – Warren Buffett

A client came to me last year after spending Rs 15,000 on a comprehensive financial plan from a “cheap” advisor. The plan was a 60-page PDF that recommended he put 70% of his retirement savings into a single mid-cap fund – the fund that the advisor was earning the highest commission from.

He paid Rs 15,000. His financial plan was going to cost him Rs 40-50 lakh over the next 20 years in inferior fund returns and wrong asset allocation.

This is the fundamental problem with the “how much does a financial planner charge?” question. People are asking about price when they should be asking about value. And they are shopping for the lowest fee when they should be shopping for alignment of interests.

⚡ Quick Answer

Financial planning fees in India range from Rs 15,000 for a basic one-time plan to Rs 1,00,000+ annually for ongoing advisory from a boutique fee-only firm. But the fee model matters more than the amount. A fee-only SEBI-registered RIA charges you directly and earns no commission. A commission-based advisor earns from product manufacturers – and their fee to you may be zero, but their advice is not neutral. Always know how your planner earns.

Financial Plan vs Financial Planning

Most clients ask for a financial plan. What they actually need is financial planning.

A financial plan is a document. It is a point-in-time snapshot of your financial situation with recommendations on what to do. It is the wedding – the event. Financial planning is the ongoing process of adapting your strategy as your life changes: your income grows, your children’s education costs become real, your retirement date approaches, your health changes, your priorities shift. It is the marriage – the journey.

Most low-cost one-time plans are just a document. The planner collects data, writes a plan, and the relationship ends. The client implements (or doesn’t), and nobody reviews whether it worked. That is a wedding without a marriage.

Good financial planning is a relationship. The plan is the reference document. The value is in the ongoing conversations, the course corrections, the behavioural coaching during market crashes, and the tax and estate planning that gets updated every year.

The Two Types of Financial Advisors in India

Understanding the fee structure begins with understanding the regulatory landscape. In India, there are two main types of financial advisors:

First, SEBI-registered Investment Advisers (RIA) under the SEBI Investment Advisers Regulations, 2013. These advisors are legally required to act in your best interest (fiduciary standard), charge fees directly to you, and cannot earn commissions from products they recommend. They are fee-only by regulation.

Second, mutual fund distributors (with ARN from AMFI) and insurance agents (with IRDA-registered companies). These earn commissions from the products they sell. Some also charge a fee, making them “fee-based” but not “fee-only.” Their income depends on the products they recommend, which creates a structural conflict of interest regardless of their personal integrity.

✅ Fee-Only vs Fee-Based: Know the Difference

Fee-only: advisor earns only from your fee. No commissions. Full fiduciary. Only possible under SEBI RIA registration. Fee-based: advisor charges a fee AND earns commissions. Still a conflict of interest. Commission-based only (no fee): advisor earns only from product commissions. Their “advice” is free to you, but you pay through product costs and potentially unsuitable recommendations.

What Should Financial Planning Actually Cost?

The real question is not what planners charge – it is what it costs to run a genuinely good practice. Consider what a legitimate boutique financial planning firm needs to operate.

A principal planner who dedicates 100% of their time to 80-120 client families needs to earn enough to make the practice sustainable. This person is your advisor, your coach, your financial doctor. Their time and expertise are worth what they would earn in other senior financial roles.

Operating costs include paraplanning software, compliance (SEBI registration, annual compliance audit), office rent, financial planning software subscriptions, continuous education (CFP certification maintenance, conferences), and staff salaries. For a 3-5 person boutique firm, these costs are real and significant.

When you add a reasonable owner income, staff costs, operating expenses, and 25-30% profit margin (to fund the practice through lean periods), the minimum fee per client that makes a 100-client boutique practice financially viable is typically Rs 30,000-60,000 per year.

The Math Most Clients Never See

The question is not whether Rs 50,000 per year is expensive. It is whether Rs 50,000 per year is value-positive.

The DALBAR Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behaviour (US study, updated annually) consistently shows that average equity investors underperform the market index by 3-5% annually due to behavioural errors – buying high, selling low, switching funds at the wrong time. In India, SEBI’s 2023 study shows comparable underperformance.

On a Rs 1 crore retirement portfolio, a 3% behavioural gap = Rs 30,000 per year in foregone returns. A Rs 50,000 planner fee that eliminates even half that gap breaks even immediately. If the planner also optimises your tax (NPS 80CCD(1B) = Rs 15,600 saved in 30% bracket), reviews your insurance, and stops you making one bad investment decision, the fee pays for itself several times over in Year 1.

The Rs 15,000 plan that put my client in a high-commission mid-cap fund was not cheap. It was expensive – because the cost was hidden in his future returns. A Rs 50,000 fee-only advisor would have been the cheapest financial decision he made that year.

Before asking what a planner charges, ask how they get paid.

RetireWise is a SEBI-registered fee-only RIA. No commissions. No product sales. Your interest is the only interest.

See How RetireWise Works

Why People Resist Paying for Advice

A client told me: “I paid Rs 40,000 annual fee to a mutual fund distributor implicitly in higher expense ratios on regular plans. But I resist paying Rs 40,000 explicitly to a fee-only planner.” He understood the logic. He still felt the resistance.

This is the Pain of Paying – a well-documented phenomenon in behavioural economics (Prelec & Loewenstein, 1998). Direct, visible payments cause disproportionate psychological discomfort compared to hidden costs of the same magnitude. Paying 1.5% TER on a regular mutual fund plan costs Rs 15,000 per year on a Rs 10 lakh investment. Most investors never feel this. Paying Rs 15,000 directly to an advisor creates immediate, visible discomfort.

The result: people choose “free” financial advice that costs them far more in hidden fees and inferior outcomes, over “expensive” fee-only advice that actually serves their interests.

As of 2026, SEBI has approximately 1,300+ registered RIAs in India. For a population of 1.4 billion with roughly 30 million HNI households, this is a severe shortage. Most Indians who can afford fee-only advice cannot find it – which is why commission-based advisors continue to dominate. The difference between a regular mutual fund plan and a direct plan is approximately 0.5-1.5% annually. On a Rs 25 lakh portfolio, this is Rs 12,500-37,500 per year – often more than the fee a genuinely good fee-only advisor would charge.

The Harish Salve Analogy

Two lawyers: Harish Salve, former Solicitor General of India, who charges approximately Rs 30 lakh per day. And a junior advocate at Rs 3,000 per hearing.

Both are lawyers. Both have law degrees. The price difference is not about the paperwork. It is about the outcome you need.

For a routine property registration, the junior advocate is fine. For a Supreme Court case where the outcome determines your company’s future, Harish Salve is not expensive. He is necessary.

Financial planning is similar. For a 25-year-old with a simple SIP and one insurance policy, a free robo-advisor may be adequate. For a 48-year-old executive with Rs 2 crore in investments, a home loan, business income, ESOP vesting schedule, retirement in 12 years, and three financial goals competing for the same rupee – a qualified, experienced fee-only planner is not a cost. It is a necessity.

“A financial planner who is not earning adequately cannot serve you well for long. Quality people will move to other professions. You want your advisor to still be there – and still be motivated – in year 10, not just year 1.”

– Hemant Beniwal, CFP, CTEP | Founder, RetireWise

Read next: Do You Need a Financial Planner? 7 Honest Reasons – and When You Don’t

The right question is not what does a planner cost. It is what does not having one cost.

RetireWise works with senior executives on retirement planning. Fee-only. No product sales. SEBI Registered RIA INA100001927.

See the RetireWise Service

The client who paid Rs 15,000 for a bad plan came back after two years. He paid Rs 60,000 for a RetireWise engagement. He called it the best financial decision of the year – because the first question we asked him was: “Who is this plan really designed to serve – you, or your previous advisor?”

Before asking what a planner charges, ask how they get paid. That answer tells you everything you need to know.

💬 Your Turn

How does your current advisor earn? Direct fee, product commission, or both? Do you know the total amount they have earned from your portfolio in the last 12 months? These are questions worth calculating before your next review.

3 Principles and 3 Practices for Superior Lifetime Investment Returns

Hemant Beniwal
-
34
3 Principles and 3 Practices for Superior Lifetime Investment Returns

In March 2020, the Sensex fell 38% in 40 days. In October 2021, it was at an all-time high. In October 2022, it corrected 16% on concerns about US rate hikes. In September 2024, it crossed 85,000.

Every one of those events generated the same response from media and anxious investors: panic, predictions of further collapse, urgent advice to exit. Every one of those events turned out to be temporary. The investors who did nothing – who held their plan when everything around them said to abandon it – came out far ahead of those who acted on the noise.

This post is about why that happens, and what it takes to be the investor who holds.

The framework here comes from Nick Murray, the American advisor-coach who influenced how I think about investing. My firm name – Ark – is itself drawn from one of his books. The 3 Principles and 3 Practices below are not complex. They are, however, consistently difficult to follow. And they account for perhaps 90% of long-term investment success.

What Are “Superior Lifetime Returns”?

Not the maximum possible return. Not the return a hypothetical perfect-timing investor would have earned. Superior lifetime returns are the returns that, sustained over decades, are sufficient to achieve all your financial goals with minimum stress and without making bad decisions at the wrong time. For most Indian equity investors, this means staying invested through multiple 20 to 40% market falls and not panicking out. The math works if the behaviour works.

3 Principles 3 Practices Superior Lifetime Returns

The 3 Principles

1. Faith

Faith is not hope. Hope is what you feel when you want something to happen without evidence. Faith is what you have when the evidence is clear, the history is consistent, and you have chosen to act on it regardless of short-term noise.

The evidence for Indian equities is clear. The Sensex was approximately 1,000 in 1990. It crossed 85,000 in 2024 – a 85x return, roughly 14% CAGR over 34 years. That 34-year period included 1992 (Harshad Mehta scam), 1997 (Asian financial crisis), 2000-2001 (dot-com crash and 9/11), 2008 (global financial crisis, -52% fall), 2016 (demonetisation), 2020 (COVID crash, -38% in 40 days), and multiple election-related panics.

Every one of those events felt like a permanent change. None of them were. The investor with faith in the long-term trajectory of Indian equities – not hope that it would recover, but faith based on 40 years of evidence – did not need to predict which event would cause the next fall, or when recovery would come. They simply held.

Faith has to be based on data, not optimism. Read the data on Indian equity market history before every panic, not during it.

2. Patience

Warren Buffett described the stock market as “a highly effective mechanism for the transfer of wealth from the impatient to the patient.” This is not a metaphor. It describes the actual mechanism by which long-term equity investors consistently outperform short-term traders.

The impatient investor, when markets fall, does the following: exits to “wait for recovery,” misses the fastest days of the recovery (which typically come immediately after the worst days), re-enters later at higher prices, and ends up with significantly lower returns than if they had simply held. This is not a theoretical failure – it is documented across investor behaviour studies in every market cycle.

The critical insight about patience: if you exit now and wait to re-enter, you are taking responsibility for being right twice – once when you exit (you need to exit at or near the top), and once when you re-enter (you need to re-enter at or near the bottom). Almost nobody gets both right. The attempt to time the market nearly always destroys more value than the original fall would have.

The patient investor’s single advantage is refusing to play the timing game. It sounds passive. Over 20 years, it is the most powerful active choice available.

3. Discipline

Patience prevents wrong action. Discipline ensures right action continues. The right action, in most cases, is maintaining your SIP regardless of market conditions.

In the March 2020 crash, mutual fund SIP cancellations spiked. Investors stopped their SIPs at exactly the moment they were buying the most units per rupee invested. By December 2020, the market had fully recovered. Those who cancelled their SIPs in March 2020 and did not restart until September missed both the cheapest units and the recovery.

Discipline also means rebalancing when markets have moved significantly in one direction – selling the asset class that has overperformed and buying the one that has underperformed. This is emotionally difficult (you are selling the winner and buying the loser) but mechanically produces better returns over time. It requires a written investment policy that you follow regardless of feelings.

“Principles dictate practices. If you don’t believe in the principles – if you don’t have faith that equity markets recover, patience to hold through the falls, and discipline to keep investing – then the practices that follow will feel counterproductive and you will abandon them at the worst time.”

The 3 Practices

1. Asset Allocation

Asset allocation is the proportion of your portfolio held in different asset classes: equity, debt, gold, real estate, cash. It is the single most important portfolio decision you will make – more important than which specific funds or stocks you choose within each asset class.

Research consistently shows that asset allocation decisions explain approximately 90% of the variability in long-term portfolio returns. The specific securities or funds chosen within each allocation explain far less. Yet most investors spend most of their time on fund selection and almost no time on asset allocation.

The right asset allocation depends on your time horizon, risk tolerance (genuine financial resilience to absorb a 30-40% fall, not just psychological attitude), and income stability. For a 45-year-old with a 15-year horizon to retirement and stable employment, 60 to 70% equity is appropriate. For a 60-year-old who has just retired and needs to draw from the portfolio, 40 to 50% equity with a bucket structure for near-term needs is more appropriate. There is no universal number – only the right allocation for your specific situation.

2. Diversification

Diversification within each asset class reduces concentration risk without sacrificing expected returns. Within equity, this means not holding more than 3 to 4 mutual funds (more creates overlap and pseudo-diversification), ensuring coverage across large-cap, mid-cap, and potentially flexi-cap categories depending on your risk tolerance, and not concentrating in any single sector. Within debt, it means spreading across PPF (government-backed, tax-free), short-duration funds (liquid), and NPS (retirement-specific).

The key principle: you will never predict the best-performing asset class or fund in advance. Diversification ensures you own enough of what turns out to perform best, without holding so much of any single thing that failure destroys the portfolio.

For retirement investors specifically: avoid the common mistake of concentrating in real estate (illiquid, concentrated in one asset) or FDs (inflation risk) while calling it “safe.” True diversification means owning assets whose returns are not perfectly correlated – equity and debt move differently over time, which is why the combination reduces volatility without reducing returns proportionally.

3. Rebalancing

Rebalancing is the practice of periodically returning your portfolio to its target asset allocation. If your target is 60% equity and 40% debt, and a strong equity run has pushed the allocation to 75/25, rebalancing means selling some equity and moving proceeds to debt until 60/40 is restored.

This sounds simple. It is psychologically difficult because it requires selling the outperforming asset (equity, when it is rising) and buying the underperforming one (debt). It feels wrong. It is, in fact, a disciplined form of buying low and selling high – the opposite of what most investors do emotionally.

Rebalancing frequency: annual rebalancing is sufficient for most investors. Some advisors use a threshold-based approach (rebalance when any asset class moves more than 5% from target), which is also effective. The key is to set the trigger in advance and follow it mechanically, not based on how you feel about the market at the time.

A Goal-Focused Investment Strategy for Retirement

RetireWise builds retirement portfolios around these three principles and three practices – with explicit asset allocation, structured diversification, and annual rebalancing built into every client relationship. Explore our approach.

See Our Services

One question for you: In the March 2020 crash, what did you do with your equity portfolio – hold, reduce, or increase? And looking back, do you wish you had done something differently?

Indian Equities: Past, Present and Future – A 2026 Update for Retirement Investors

Hemant Beniwal
-
47
Indian Equities: Past, Present and Future – A 2026 Update for Retirement Investors

“History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.” – Mark Twain

I started my career in 2003. It was the worst time to be new to the investment industry.

The Sensex was around 3,000. The tech bubble had burst three years earlier and investors were still counting their losses. The mood was grim. Every experienced person I met told me equities were finished – that the market would never recover meaningfully. Real estate was going through a secular bear market. The economy felt broken.

I did not know it then, but I had joined at the beginning of one of the greatest equity bull runs in Indian history. From 3,000 in 2003, the Sensex would reach 21,000 by 2007. Fourteen years of compounding from that low. The clients who stayed invested through 2003 and 2004 – against all the noise – were the ones who built real wealth.

Twenty-three years later, I find myself thinking about that period often. Because 2025-26 feels like another moment where the noise is louder than the signal, and the fundamentals of the Indian equity story remain intact in ways most investors are too distracted to notice.

⚡ Quick Answer

Indian equities have delivered roughly 14-15% CAGR over 20-year periods – among the best in the world. The structural case for Indian equity in 2026 rests on demographics, domestic consumption, infrastructure investment, financialisation of savings, and a growing middle class. Short-term volatility is real and unpredictable. Long-term direction, for a patient investor with a 10-15 year horizon, is one of the clearest conviction calls available. This post explains why – and what it means for your retirement portfolio.

Indian equities - past performance, current landscape, and future outlook for retirement investors

The Past: What Indian Equities Have Actually Delivered

Let me use specific numbers, because the equity story in India is almost always better than memory suggests.

The Sensex was approximately 1,000 in 1990. It crossed 10,000 in 2006. 30,000 in 2019. 80,000 in 2024. The 34-year journey from 1,000 to 80,000 represents a CAGR of approximately 14%. But the real compounding power shows up not in the Sensex itself but in the dividends and corporate earnings growth underneath it.

This return history includes: the 1992 Harshad Mehta scam, the 1997 Asian financial crisis, the 2000 tech bubble, the 2008 global financial crisis (Sensex fell 60% in 12 months), the 2011-2013 long sideways market, the 2020 COVID crash (fell 38% in 6 weeks), and the 2022 rate-hike-driven correction. In every single one of these crashes, the market recovered and went on to new highs within 2-5 years.

The investor who stayed invested through all of these – through every newspaper headline predicting collapse, through every well-meaning friend who said “this time is different” – built extraordinary wealth. The investor who tried to exit during crashes and re-enter at the bottom almost universally earned less than the one who did nothing.

“In 23 years in Indian financial markets, I have never seen a 10-year period where equity did not deliver positive real returns. And I have seen many periods where investors exited early and regretted it for the rest of their financial lives.”

– Hemant Beniwal, CFP, CTEP | Founder, RetireWise

The Present: Where Indian Equities Stand in 2026

After the strong 2023-2024 run, Indian markets corrected meaningfully in 2025 – mid and small caps more than large caps. As of early 2026, valuations are more reasonable than they were at peak 2024 levels, though not cheap by historical standards. The Nifty 50 trades at approximately 18-19x forward earnings, which is slightly above long-term average but not in bubble territory.

Importantly, the correction has shaken out the most speculative participants. The froth in small-cap and thematic funds that built up in 2023-24 has partially deflated. This is healthy. Markets that never correct do not give new investors an opportunity to enter at sensible valuations.

Domestic flows into equity mutual funds remain strong – monthly SIP contributions have been running above Rs 25,000 crore throughout 2025, reflecting the structural shift of Indian household savings from physical assets and FDs toward equity. This is a new and important development: domestic investors are increasingly providing a floor that was not present in earlier corrections dominated by FII selling.

How much equity should you hold in your retirement portfolio right now?

The right allocation depends on your timeline, corpus size, and risk capacity – not on where markets happen to be today. A RetireWise advisor can map this for your specific situation.

Book a Free 30-Min Call

The Structural Case for Indian Equity: Five Long-Term Drivers

Demographics. India has approximately 600 million people under the age of 25 – the largest young population of any major economy. This cohort will enter the workforce, increase consumption, save, and invest over the next 20-30 years. Corporate India’s addressable market will grow with this demographic wave in a way that no amount of policy uncertainty can fully offset.

Financialisation of savings. India’s household savings are historically locked in physical assets – gold and real estate – and conservative instruments like FDs and insurance. The shift toward equity is in its early stages. Mutual fund folios have grown from 4 crore in 2015 to over 20 crore in 2025. Insurance premiums, EPF contributions, and NPS assets are growing. As more Indian household savings rotate toward equity over the next decade, domestic institutional support for the market increases structurally.

Infrastructure investment. India’s capital expenditure on roads, railways, ports, airports, data centres, and power infrastructure has accelerated significantly since 2020. Infrastructure investment creates corporate earnings across multiple sectors – cement, steel, engineering, logistics, construction – that compound for years after the investment is made.

Formalisation of the economy. GST implementation, digital payments, Aadhaar-linked systems, and increased tax compliance have brought large parts of the informal economy into the formal sector. Formal companies gain market share from informal competitors. Corporate earnings in organised sectors grow faster than nominal GDP as formalisation continues.

Global supply chain shifts. The China-plus-one strategy adopted by global manufacturers since 2020 has created opportunities for Indian manufacturing – electronics, pharmaceuticals, textiles, and speciality chemicals. This is a 10-15 year trend, not a quarterly event.

The Risks: What Could Derail the Story

Balanced analysis requires acknowledging real risks. Indian equity is not risk-free.

Geopolitical risk at the borders – while contained historically – is always present. Global risk-off events (US recession, China slowdown, commodity price shocks) hit Indian markets hard in the short term even when Indian fundamentals are sound. Domestic policy risk – particularly around taxation, capital markets regulation, or electoral outcomes – creates periodic uncertainty. Corporate governance remains uneven across sectors and company sizes.

And valuations matter at the margin. Buying good businesses at bad prices produces poor returns even over long periods. The investors who bought in January 2008, at Sensex 21,000, had to wait until 2014 to get back to even. A 6-year wait is manageable if you have 20 years ahead of you; it is devastating if you are 3 years from retirement.

This is why asset allocation – not a blanket “invest in equity” directive – is the right framework. The question is not whether Indian equity is a good long-term investment. It is: how much of your specific corpus, given your specific timeline, belongs in equity?

What This Means for Retirement Investors Specifically

For a 45-year-old building a retirement corpus: a 60-65% equity allocation in a diversified portfolio is appropriate and well-supported by the structural case above. The 15-year horizon absorbs short-term corrections and participates in the long-term compounding story.

For a 55-year-old within 5 years of retirement: the allocation should be gliding down toward 40-50% equity, with the remainder in stable debt instruments. The structural case is still valid, but sequence-of-returns risk matters more as the retirement date approaches.

For a 65-year-old in retirement: 30-40% equity in the long-term bucket, with 5-7 years of expenses in stable instruments. Enough equity to ensure the corpus outlasts the retirement period; enough stability to ensure short-term income needs are never at the mercy of market timing.

The structural story of Indian equities – demographics, domestic consumption, financialisation, infrastructure – plays out over 20-30 years. A retirement portfolio built for a 25-year retirement is exactly the right vehicle to capture it.

Read – Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP): The Right Way to Take Income in Retirement

Read – Asset Allocation: The Real Secret Behind High Investment Returns

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it still a good time to invest in Indian equity in 2026?

The honest answer: it is almost always a good time to invest in Indian equity for a 10-15 year horizon, regardless of where markets are today. Trying to find the perfect entry point is market timing – which consistently underperforms staying invested. If you have surplus money and a long enough horizon, start a SIP immediately. If you have a lump sum, deploy it systematically over 6-12 months using a Systematic Transfer Plan to avoid concentrating at any one price level.

How much should I have in Indian equity versus international equity?

For most Indian retail investors, a 10-15% allocation to international equity (primarily US-focused index funds) provides meaningful diversification without overcomplicating the portfolio. India’s growth story is strong, but having some exposure to the global technology sector and US dollar assets provides a hedge against INR depreciation and India-specific risks. SEBI’s restrictions on foreign fund investment have eased somewhat but still apply – check current limits before investing.

I am 50 and have never invested in equity. Is it too late to start?

Not too late, but the timeline shapes the approach. A 50-year-old with a 10-year horizon to retirement and a 25-year retirement period thereafter has 35 years of potential investment horizon – 10 of accumulation and 25 of drawdown. Starting with a 40-50% equity allocation, building toward 55-60% over 3-5 years as you build familiarity with volatility, and then gliding down as you approach 60, is a reasonable path. The key discipline is not exiting in the first significant correction – which usually arrives in the first 2-3 years for any new equity investor.

The investors who were sitting in my office in 2003, looking at a Sensex of 3,000 and wondering if equities were finished, had no idea what the next 20 years would bring. Neither do the investors sitting in their offices in 2026, looking at market corrections and wondering if the story is over. The story is not over. It has barely started.

Do the Right Thing and Sit Tight.

Want a retirement portfolio built on the right equity allocation for your stage of life?

RetireWise builds retirement plans that match equity exposure to timeline, risk capacity, and specific retirement income needs.

See Our Retirement Planning Service

💬 Your Turn

What is your current equity allocation – and does it match your retirement timeline? Have you ever exited equity during a correction and then struggled to re-enter? Share your experience in the comments.

Financial Lessons for Kids: What to Teach and When (An Age-by-Age Guide for Indian Parents)

Hemant Beniwal
-
14
Financial Lessons for Kids: What to Teach and When (An Age-by-Age Guide for Indian Parents)

“Children are great imitators. So give them something great to imitate.” – Anonymous

If you ask a 5-year-old where money comes from, the answer is almost always “the ATM.” Which is not wrong – they are just reporting what they have observed. The connection between the ATM and the work that funds it is invisible to them.

That invisibility does not correct itself automatically as children grow. Without deliberate financial education at home, children develop their money beliefs from advertising, peer pressure, and whatever they observe in adult spending behavior. By the time they are earning their first salary, the patterns are largely set.

The parents who get this right are not the ones who give the most pocket money or buy the most toys. They are the ones who treat money as a topic that can be discussed honestly and progressively, at each stage of their child’s development.

⚡ Quick Answer

Financial education for children works best when it is age-appropriate, experiential rather than theoretical, and modelled by parents rather than just taught. The core sequence: ages 5-7 (what money is, where it comes from), ages 7-9 (saving for goals, distinguishing needs from wants), ages 9-13 (compounding, debt, basic investment concepts), ages 13+ (budgeting, delayed gratification, understanding financial risk). The most important thing you can teach a child about money is that it is earned, it is finite, and choices have consequences.

Financial lessons for kids - age-by-age guide for Indian parents

Ages 5-7: What Is Money and Where Does It Come From?

At this age, abstract financial concepts are inaccessible. But concrete, observable lessons are not. The goal is simply to replace “the ATM gives money” with “work earns money, which goes to the ATM.”

Start by showing physical currency. Indian notes come in multiple denominations with very different values – have the child identify them, count combinations, and understand that prices represent specific amounts. The Rs 10 ice cream and the Rs 200 toy are different not because one is “expensive” and one is “cheap” but because one costs more money, which means more work.

The work connection is the crucial lesson at this age. When you drop your child to school and leave for work, tell them that you miss them too – but that you go to work so the family has money for food, school, and the things they love. You work for the month; the money comes to your account; you withdraw it from the ATM when needed. At age 6, this is entirely comprehensible – and it corrects the “ATM gives free money” misconception that generates so much unrealistic demanding behavior.

The second lesson: everything has a cost. The fruits at the vegetable vendor, the electricity that runs the fan, the petrol in the car, the school fees – these are not free. Naming these costs while shopping creates an awareness that resources are finite, even if the amounts are not yet understood.

Ages 7-9: Saving for Goals and Distinguishing Wants from Needs

This is the age to introduce pocket money – and to use it as an experiential teaching tool rather than simply allowance. The amount matters less than the structure.

When your child wants something – a new tablet, a particular toy, a trip to a water park – use it as an opportunity to teach goal-based saving. Tell them what it costs, how much they receive per month, and how many months of saving it will take. Help them track the progress. When they finally spend their saved money, the satisfaction is qualitatively different from money given on demand – and the lesson about deferred gratification is permanently learned from experience, not lecture.

This is also the age to introduce the difference between routine expenses and goal-based saving. When you take the child grocery shopping, explain that food is a routine expense that happens every week. When you show them the school fees receipt or the family vacation planning, explain that these are goals you save for over time. The grasshopper and the ant story exists for a reason – the concept of sacrificing current consumption to fund future goals is exactly this old and exactly this universal.

The habits that determine financial outcomes as adults are formed before age 12.

RetireWise works with families to ensure that while you are building your own retirement corpus, you are also building the financial frameworks your children will carry forward. Both matter.

See How RetireWise Approaches Family Financial Planning

Ages 9-13: Compounding, Debt, and Basic Investment Concepts

By this age, children can handle more abstract concepts – provided they are introduced through concrete examples rather than textbook definitions.

The power of compounding is best taught through a simple calculation: if you put Rs 1,000 in a savings account at 4% interest and leave it for 10 years, how much do you have? Do the calculation together. Then show what happens if they add Rs 100 per month. The numbers are not large – but the principle of money earning money, and that time is the most powerful ingredient, lands viscerally at this age.

Debt is equally important – and the lesson here is about cost. Show them how a credit card works: you buy something today and pay later, but if you do not pay on time, you pay significantly more than the original price. Use round numbers: “This Rs 10,000 purchase, if we only pay the minimum on the credit card, actually costs Rs 13,000-14,000 by the time it’s fully paid.” Home loan EMI calculations are also accessible at this age – and the concept that a Rs 50 lakh home costs Rs 90 lakh+ over 20 years at EMI rates is genuinely surprising to most adults, let alone children.

At this age, a child can also start a recurring deposit in their own name with their pocket money savings. Having an actual bank account – and watching the interest compound monthly – is a more effective teacher than any amount of explanation.

Ages 13 and Above: Budgeting, Delayed Gratification, and Financial Risk

The teenage years are when peer pressure and advertising exert maximum influence on financial behavior. A child who has had consistent money education up to this point has the frameworks to process this pressure. One who has not is particularly vulnerable.

At this age, the lessons should become more collaborative. Share the household budget with your teenager – the actual numbers for groceries, utilities, school fees, EMIs, insurance premiums, and savings. Let them understand what a month’s expenses look like, and where their spending fits within it. This is not about creating anxiety – it is about building contextual awareness.

Introduce the concept of financial risk through relatable examples. The friend who spent their entire Diwali gift on one purchase has no buffer for an unexpected need. The cousin who borrowed money to buy a phone is paying interest for months. These real-world examples from their social circle are far more effective than theoretical risk discussions.

A teenager can also begin to understand the difference between speculative and investment behavior – particularly relevant in an era when stories of crypto gains and stock market wins circulate constantly in peer groups. The lesson is not “investing is dangerous” but “investing requires purpose, timeline, and understanding what you own.”

Before You Teach: Model It First

Children learn far more from what they observe than from what they are told. A parent who says “save money” but upgrades their phone every year on credit, or who treats money as a topic too sensitive to discuss openly, teaches a more powerful lesson than any formal financial education.

The prerequisites for effective financial parenting are simple: make money a normal topic rather than a source of tension or secrecy. Show respect for money in your own financial decisions. Let children see you being thoughtful about purchases rather than impulsive. And be honest when a purchase requires saving first, rather than simply presenting everything as immediately available.

The child who grows up in a home where money is discussed calmly, honestly, and progressively will carry those frameworks into their adult financial life. The investment you make in their financial education costs nothing and compounds indefinitely.

Read: 10 Money Lessons to Teach Your Kids (And Why It Matters for Your Retirement Too)

The most valuable financial gift you can give your child is not a fixed deposit in their name. It is a set of beliefs and habits that will serve them for the rest of their lives. Those are built slowly, at home, through consistent conversation and example.

Teach early. Model always. Compound forever.

Are you building wealth for your children – or teaching them to build their own?

RetireWise helps families think through both dimensions – the financial corpus you are building for your children’s goals, and the financial education that will outlast any corpus.

Book a Free 30-Min Call

Your Turn

What was the most effective money lesson you received as a child – from a parent, a teacher, or an experience? Or if you are a parent now, what approach has worked best with your own children? Share in the comments.

Is Rs 1 Crore Enough to Retire in India?

Hemant Beniwal
-
21
Is Rs 1 Crore Enough to Retire in India?

Jab Kaun Banega Crorepati shuru hua, log pagal ho gaye the. “Rs 1 Crore! Zindagi ban jayegi!”

That was the year 2000. Twenty-six years ago.

Today, Rs 1 Crore won’t buy you a decent 2BHK in most metros. It won’t fund your child’s foreign education. And as I’m about to show you — it probably won’t fund even half your retirement.

I’ve been advising Indian families on retirement for over two decades now. And the single most dangerous belief I still encounter is this: “Ek crore ho jayega toh life set hai.”

Let me break this belief with numbers. Not to scare you — but to prepare you.

⚡ Quick Answer

For most Indian families, Rs 1 Crore is not enough to retire comfortably. At 6% inflation, a family spending ₹50,000/month today will need ₹1.6 lakh/month at age 60 (if they’re 40 now) — requiring a corpus of ₹3.8 Crore, not ₹1 Crore. Only if your monthly expenses are under ₹25,000 AND you retire in the next 5 years might ₹1 Crore stretch enough.

Illustration showing whether Rs 1 crore retirement corpus is sufficient for Indian families at different age groups and expense levels

The Villain You Can’t See — Inflation

Remember Bollywood movies from the 80s and 90s? Villains were doing diamond deals for lakhs and kidnapping kids for thousands. Today’s movies throw around crores like loose change.

That shift? That’s inflation. Silent, invisible, relentless.

India’s CPI inflation has moderated to around 3-4% recently, but here’s what most people miss: healthcare inflation in India runs at 10-14% annually. And after 60, healthcare becomes your biggest expense — not groceries, not rent, not EMIs.

For retirement planning, a 6% blended inflation rate is the minimum you should assume. If you want to be truly safe, plan for 7%.

Now let me show you what this villain actually does to your ₹1 Crore dream.

Three Families, One Crore, One Dream — Let’s Do the Maths

I’m going to show you three real families I’ve worked with (names changed). Same dream — comfortable retirement. Same magic number — Rs 1 Crore. Very different wake-up calls.

Our planning assumptions for 2026:

  • Retirement age: 60 years
  • Life expectancy: 85 years (living longer is actually a risk in retirement — more years to fund)
  • Inflation: 6% (blended — CPI + healthcare weighting)
  • Post-tax portfolio return: 8% (Debt 60% @ 7.5% + Equity 40% @ 11.5%)

Family 1: Sharma Ji — Age 55, Mumbai

Sharma Ji (name changed) and his wife have worked hard all their lives. Kids are well settled — no financial dependents. No loans. They expect to retire in 5 years with Rs 1 Crore saved up.

“Bas itna chahiye ki aaraam se zindagi kat jaaye,” he told me. Small luxuries. Occasional travel. Nothing extravagant.

Then I showed him this table:

Monthly Expenses Today → ₹30,000 ₹50,000 ₹75,000 ₹1,00,000
Monthly Expenses at 60 (5 years later) ₹40,147 ₹66,911 ₹1,00,367 ₹1,33,823
Retirement Corpus Required ₹95 Lakh ₹1.59 Cr ₹2.38 Cr ₹3.18 Cr

Sharma Ji was relieved initially — at ₹30,000/month, his ₹1 Crore just about covers it. But then he honestly added up his expenses: medicines, household help, society maintenance, occasional travel to see grandchildren, festival gifts. The real number was closer to ₹65,000 a month.

His ₹1 Crore covers barely half of what he actually needs.

If you’re close to retirement and feeling this panic — take a breath and read about the best retirement plan options available in India right now.

Family 2: Singh Sahab — Age 40, Delhi

Mr Singh (name changed) works at an MNC. Two daughters in school. “Best” education is the top priority — retirement comes later, he says. He’s made investments for every goal, but unfortunately most are in insurance products that were mis-sold to him.

He’s burning out. Thoughts of early retirement float through his mind. But he still holds on to that magical ₹1 Crore target — it feels achievable, comfortable, safe.

Let’s see if it is:

Monthly Expenses Today → ₹30,000 ₹50,000 ₹75,000 ₹1,00,000
Monthly Expenses at 60 (20 years later) ₹96,214 ₹1,60,357 ₹2,40,535 ₹3,20,714
Retirement Corpus Required ₹2.28 Cr ₹3.81 Cr ₹5.71 Cr ₹7.62 Cr

Singh Sahab’s ₹50,000/month Delhi lifestyle needs ₹3.81 Crore at retirement. His ₹1 Crore dream covers barely 26% of the actual requirement.

The good news? He still has 20 years. Time is his greatest asset — but only if he stops delaying and starts a proper retirement savings strategy using the right instruments.

Family 3: Agarwal — Age 30, Bangalore

Agarwal (name changed) is in IT, earning well, married two years ago — love marriage, parents weren’t thrilled initially. Both spouses work. Zero savings. “Retirement? That’s 30 years away, yaar. Chill karo.”

When I told him that ₹1 Crore might not even cover his first year of retirement expenses at his current lifestyle — he laughed.

Then I showed him the numbers:

Monthly Expenses Today → ₹30,000 ₹50,000 ₹75,000 ₹1,00,000
Monthly Expenses at 60 (30 years later) ₹1,72,305 ₹2,87,174 ₹4,30,762 ₹5,74,349
Retirement Corpus Required ₹4.09 Cr ₹6.82 Cr ₹10.23 Cr ₹13.64 Cr

He stopped laughing.

Even at ₹30,000/month (which barely covers rent + food for a Bangalore couple), he’d need over ₹4 Crore. At his realistic ₹75,000/month lifestyle, the number crosses ₹10 Crore.

I told him — the maths doesn’t care about your feelings. But time is still entirely on your side. Start a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) strategy now and the compounding will do the heavy lifting.

⚠️ Healthcare — The Expense Nobody Plans For

These calculations use 6% blended inflation. But healthcare inflation in India runs at 10-14%. After age 70, medical expenses can eat 30-40% of your monthly budget. Keep an additional emergency health buffer of ₹20-30 Lakh — and ensure you have adequate health insurance in place before you retire.

Worried your retirement corpus isn’t enough?

A proper retirement analysis tells you exactly where you stand — and what to do about it.

Get Your Retirement Analysed →

The Simple Formula That Actually Works — The 25x Rule

After working with hundreds of families across India, here’s the simplest retirement formula I’ve seen that holds up in real life:

Your retirement corpus = Your expected ANNUAL expense in the first year of retirement × 25

If your first-year retirement expenses will be ₹12 Lakh (₹1 Lakh per month), you need at least ₹3 Crore. If they’ll be ₹24 Lakh, you need ₹6 Crore.

The tricky part isn’t the multiplication — it’s honestly estimating what your expenses will be 20 or 30 years from now. That’s where the inflation factor bites. And that’s exactly where most people get the number wrong.

5 Things You Can Do Right Now — No Matter Your Age

1. Know YOUR actual number. Not ₹1 Crore. Not ₹5 Crore. YOUR number — based on YOUR expenses, YOUR age, YOUR city. Use the tables above as a starting point. Be honest about your lifestyle. Most people underestimate by 30-40%.

2. Start an SIP today. A ₹25,000/month SIP in equity mutual funds for 20 years at 12% returns can build roughly ₹2.5 Crore. That’s the power of compounding — but it works only if you start. Every year you delay costs you lakhs at the other end.

3. Max out NPS for tax savings. The National Pension System (NPS) gives you an extra ₹50,000 deduction under Section 80CCD(1B) in the old tax regime. And since December 2025, you can stay invested in NPS until age 85. The longer your money compounds, the bigger your corpus.

4. Stop mixing insurance with investment. If you’re holding ULIPs, endowment plans, or money-back policies hoping they’ll fund your retirement — you’re setting yourself up for a shortfall. Read about exit strategies for mis-sold insurance policies and move that money into proper retirement instruments. Get a good term insurance plan for protection and invest the rest separately.

5. Plan your withdrawal strategy — not just your savings. Building ₹5 Crore is step one. Knowing how to draw ₹1.5 Lakh per month without running out is step two — and it’s the step almost nobody plans for. Look into a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) combined with SCSS (Senior Citizen Savings Scheme at 8.2% interest) and a bucket strategy that separates your immediate, medium-term, and long-term needs.

And one more thing most people ignore until it’s too late: make sure your nominee and legal heir documentation is absolutely clear. The best retirement plan in the world becomes a nightmare for your family if they can’t access it.

Don’t let ₹1 Crore become a false sense of security

A personalised retirement roadmap accounts for your real expenses, real inflation, and real goals — not round numbers.

Talk to a Fee-Only Planner →

The question was never “Is ₹1 Crore enough?” The real question is — what does dignity in your last chapter actually cost?

Retirement pe compromise karna — yeh sabse mehenga compromise hai.

💬 Your Turn

What’s your current age and retirement corpus target? Drop it in the comments — I’ll tell you honestly whether you’re on track or need to course-correct.

Books by Hemant Beniwal

Hemant Beniwal
-
29
Books by Hemant Beniwal

Books by Hemant Beniwal

Practical wisdom on financial planning and investor psychology — written for real people, not textbooks.

Book 1

Financial Life Planning
Solve Your Biggest Puzzle

Published with CNBC

Financial Life Planning Book by Hemant Beniwal

A complete start-to-finish guide to financial planning. From understanding your life goals to budgeting, insurance, investments, and building a plan that works — all in one book.

🧩

Understanding the life puzzle

📐

Budgeting, debt, insurance & investments

🎯

Assembling your complete plan

Book 2

Modifying Investor Behaviour

Published by TV18 Broadcast Ltd · 282 Pages

Modifying Investor Behaviour by Hemant Beniwal

Why do smart people make bad financial decisions? This book explores the psychology behind investor behaviour — the biases, emotions, and mental traps that silently erode your wealth — and how to overcome them.

🧠

Behavioural biases in investing

📉

Why returns gap exists between fund & investor

🛡️

Strategies to make better decisions

💛 100% of the author’s royalty from both books goes towards promoting financial literacy and charitable donations.

Financial Scams Targeting Indians in 2026: How to Protect Yourself and Your Retirement

Hemant Beniwal
-
28
Financial Scams Targeting Indians in 2026: How to Protect Yourself and Your Retirement

“The most dangerous person is the one who lies, watches, and waits.”
– Laila Gifty Akita

A client called me a few years ago, agitated. “Hemant, I got an email from the Income Tax Department saying I have a refund of Rs 18,400 pending. They want my account number to transfer it. Should I give it?”

I asked him: “Did you actually file for a refund this year?”

Long pause. “No, actually I don’t think I did.”

“Then there is no refund. That email is from a fraudster.”

He had come very close to entering his account details. The email looked professional — it had the Income Tax Department logo, official-looking fonts, government colours. The only thing it did not have was any connection to the actual Income Tax Department.

That conversation was years ago. The scams have become significantly more sophisticated since then. This post is the updated version — covering every major financial fraud currently targeting Indian earners and how to protect yourself.

⚡ Quick Answer

No legitimate government department, bank, or financial institution will ever ask for your account number, OTP, UPI PIN, or password via email, SMS, or phone call. The Income Tax Department communicates only through the official portal (incometax.gov.in). Any unsolicited communication asking for financial information or offering unexpected money is a scam — regardless of how official it looks.

Financial scams phishing fraud India income tax refund lottery

Why These Scams Work — and Why Smart People Fall For Them

The most common question after a financial fraud is: “How could someone that intelligent fall for it?” The answer is that intelligence is not what protects you from scams. Awareness does.

Financial fraudsters are expert psychologists. They create urgency (“your account will be frozen in 24 hours”), authority (“this is the CBDT calling”), fear (“you have a tax default”), and unexpected good news (“you have won a lottery / your refund is ready”). These emotional triggers bypass rational thinking. When you are frightened or excited, you act first and think later. That is precisely what scammers count on.

Senior executives are actually higher-value targets than most people realise. They have more money, they transact in larger amounts, and they are accustomed to acting quickly on authoritative instructions. A scam that mimics an IT notice or a senior banker’s call is more likely to succeed with a CFO than with a college student.

The Most Common Financial Scams Targeting Indians in 2026

1. Income Tax Refund / Notice Phishing

You receive an email or SMS claiming to be from the Income Tax Department with either a refund offer or a compliance notice. The email asks you to “update your bank account” or “verify your PAN” via a link. The link leads to a fake website that looks exactly like the official portal. Any information entered goes directly to the fraudster.

The real Income Tax Department communicates only through your registered account on incometax.gov.in. It never sends refunds by asking you to submit account details via email. If you have a genuine refund due, it appears in your ITR filing status. Check directly on the portal — never follow a link from an email.

2. UPI and Digital Payment Scams

This is now the most prevalent financial fraud in India by volume. The mechanics: you receive a “collect request” on UPI that looks like a payment to you. You are told “enter your PIN to receive the money.” But entering your PIN on a collect request sends money out, not in.

The rule is absolute: you never need to enter your UPI PIN to receive money. If someone asks you to “enter your PIN to confirm receipt,” they are stealing from you. Block, report, and hang up.

A related version: “screen sharing request to help you receive payment.” The moment you grant screen access, the fraudster can see your banking apps, capture OTPs, and drain accounts. Never share your screen with anyone you did not initiate contact with.

3. Lottery / Prize / Inheritance Notifications

The classic: you have won a lottery, an iPhone, a car, a foreign prize. The email comes from a Gmail or Yahoo address, not an official domain. “Processing fees” are required to release the prize. The prize never arrives. The fees are just stolen.

The Hindi phrase applies perfectly here: “जब टिकट ही नहीं ख़रीदा तो लॉटरी कैसे खुल गयी?” If you did not enter, you cannot win.

4. KYC Expiry / Account Deactivation Threats

An SMS or WhatsApp message claiming your bank, mutual fund, or demat account KYC has expired and will be “deactivated in 48 hours.” A link is provided to “update KYC urgently.” The link is a phishing page.

Your bank will never send a WhatsApp message about KYC. KYC updates are handled at bank branches or through the bank’s own verified app after you log in directly. Never follow a link from an SMS to update banking information.

5. Investment Scams (WhatsApp / Telegram Groups)

A “financial advisor” adds you to a WhatsApp or Telegram group. The group shows screenshots of spectacular returns — 40%, 80%, 200% in weeks. You are invited to invest in “exclusive IPO allocations” or “arbitrage opportunities” through an app or website you have never heard of. Early investors receive actual returns (funded by later investors). When you invest a larger amount, the app disappears.

This is a Ponzi structure. In 2024-25, thousands of Indians lost money to these investment scams, with some cases involving Rs 10-50 lakh losses per individual. SEBI-registered advisors and portfolio managers are listed at sebi.gov.in. If someone claiming to be a financial advisor is not on that list, they are not regulated. Do not invest with them.

The “Pig Butchering” Scam — A New Danger for Senior Executives

This is an elaborate, long-running fraud that has grown significantly in India. A fraudster builds a genuine relationship with the target over weeks or months — often using a romantic or friendship angle on LinkedIn or matrimonial sites. After trust is established, they introduce an “investment platform” that shows real-looking returns. The victim invests more and more. When they try to withdraw large amounts, fees are demanded and then the platform disappears. Individual losses in India have run from Rs 20 lakh to Rs 2 crore.

The warning sign: any investment opportunity introduced through a social or personal relationship, rather than through a verifiable regulated entity, should be treated with extreme caution regardless of the “relationship” with the introducer.

6. Fake Bank / Financial Services Calls

A caller identifies themselves as your bank’s fraud department. “Sir, we have detected suspicious activity on your account. I need to verify your details to protect you.” They ask for your card number, CVV, OTP, or net banking password.

Your bank will never ask for your full card number, CVV, OTP, or net banking password on a call. If you receive such a call, hang up immediately and call your bank directly using the number on the back of your card.

How to Protect Yourself: The Non-Negotiable Rules

These rules are simple, absolute, and apply regardless of how authentic the communication looks or how urgent the situation feels.

Never share OTPs with anyone, ever — including people who claim to be from your own bank. An OTP is a one-time authorisation for a transaction. If someone else has it, they can authorise that transaction in your name. There is no legitimate reason for any employee of any institution to ask for your OTP.

Never follow links in emails or SMS messages to log into any financial account. Always go directly to the institution’s website by typing the address, or use their official verified app. Phishing sites can look pixel-perfect identical to the real thing.

Never transfer money to “safe accounts.” This is a fraud escalation tactic — the fraudster tells you your account is compromised and you need to move your money to a “safe” account they provide. That account is theirs. Your money is gone the moment it arrives.

Verify unexpected windfalls independently. An actual income tax refund will be visible in your ITR filing status on incometax.gov.in. An actual prize or lottery requires you to have entered. If you did not enter, you did not win.

Report immediately if you are targeted. The Cyber Crime helpline is 1930. The National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal is cybercrime.gov.in. Time matters — reporting within hours of a fraud significantly improves recovery chances.

The Retirement Implication

For senior executives nearing retirement with larger accumulated assets, the financial stakes of a single successful fraud are higher. A fraudster who successfully social-engineers a Rs 50 lakh transfer from a retiree’s account is targeting not just money — but years of retirement security.

Specific protections for larger accumulated assets: set up transaction alerts for all accounts. Set a daily transfer limit (most banks allow this) that requires branch verification to increase. Tell your family members about the common scam patterns — elders are often targeted because fraudsters assume they are less digitally aware. Register for Do Not Disturb (DND) with your telecom operator to reduce unsolicited calls.

Awareness is the only protection. There is no fraud-prevention technology that replaces knowing the patterns.

Share this post with your family. The person most likely to fall for a financial fraud is not you — it is someone you care about who has not read this.

RetireWise: Protecting What You Built

The government will never call you with a lottery prize. Your bank will never ask for your OTP. Urgency is always a manipulation tactic.

When in doubt, hang up, log off, and verify independently.

Building a retirement corpus takes 30 years. Losing it to a fraud takes 30 minutes.

A financial plan includes protection as much as accumulation. RetireWise builds both.

Book a Free 30-Min Call

Your Turn

Have you or someone you know encountered a financial fraud attempt? What was the trigger that made you suspicious — or what almost made it succeed? Sharing your experience in the comments could protect someone else.

Coupons, Deals and Discounts: When They Save You Money and When They Cost You Retirement

Hemant Beniwal
-
19
Coupons, Deals and Discounts: When They Save You Money and When They Cost You Retirement

“The best deal is the one where you buy something you actually needed, at a fair price. The worst deal is the one that felt like a bargain but consumed money you were saving.”

A cousin got married a few years ago. I volunteered to help with online shopping for the arrangements, figuring the internet would deliver better prices than Jaipur’s markets.

My inbox was full of “inaugural discount,” “midnight sale,” “deals ending in 2 hours.” Every site opened with a banner screaming SALE. I spent three hours comparing prices across platforms and eventually asked myself: if every shopping site is always on sale, what exactly is the original price?

That question led me to the insight that shapes how I think about discounts, deals, and the entire psychology of sale-driven spending.

⚡ Quick Answer

Sales, coupons, and deals save money only when you were going to buy the item anyway, at that price, at that time. When a sale creates a purchase you would not otherwise have made, it is not saving money. It is spending money with extra steps. The psychology of discounts is designed to override your judgment about whether you actually need something. Understanding this changes how you interact with every Amazon sale, Flipkart Big Billion Day, and “limited time offer.”

How deals and discounts affect your personal finances and retirement savings

The Discount Psychology: How It Works on You

Retailers are not offering discounts because they are generous. They are offering discounts because discounts work. The research on this is extensive.

Anchoring: when you see “MRP Rs 2,999 – Now Rs 1,499”, your brain anchors to the Rs 2,999 and evaluates the Rs 1,499 against that anchor. It feels like a Rs 1,500 saving. But if the product was never actually worth Rs 2,999 to begin with, you did not save Rs 1,500. You spent Rs 1,499.

Urgency: “Offer ends in 4 hours.” “Only 3 left at this price.” These are psychological pressure mechanisms. They short-circuit your ability to evaluate whether you actually want the product by introducing time pressure that makes thoughtful consideration feel risky.

Loss aversion: missing a discount feels like a loss, even if you were not planning to buy the product before you saw the discount. The brain treats “failing to save Rs 1,500” as equivalent to losing Rs 1,500. This is irrational but consistent – and every e-commerce platform is designed around it.

“I have never met a client who saved money by shopping more. Every rupee spent on a 50% discount on something you did not need is a full rupee gone from your retirement savings.”

– Hemant Beniwal, CFP, CTEP | Founder, RetireWise

When Deals Are Genuinely Beneficial

Not all discount-driven purchasing is irrational. There are situations where using coupons and sale pricing is genuinely smart financial behaviour.

Buying something you had already planned to buy. If you need a new laptop and you know a sale is coming, waiting for that sale is rational. The decision to buy was already made. The discount simply reduces the cost of an already-committed purchase.

Buying consumables in bulk at a significant discount. Grocery staples, household supplies, personal care products. If the discount is real (not manufactured), the product has a long shelf life, and you have storage, buying in bulk at a sale price is genuinely cost-effective. The key qualifier: these are items you will definitely consume.

Using cashback and credit card rewards on planned spending. If you are going to spend on insurance, travel, or utilities anyway, routing these through a card that gives 1-2% cashback or reward points on planned expenditure is a small but legitimate saving. The discipline required: do not let the rewards justify spending you would not otherwise make.

Is lifestyle spending absorbing what should be going to your retirement?

A RetireWise retirement plan identifies the gap between current savings and retirement target – and maps exactly what lifestyle choices are creating it.

Book a Free 30-Min Call

When Deals Hurt Your Finances

Buying something you would not have bought without the sale. This is the core problem. The sale did not save you money. It cost you money that would otherwise have stayed in your account. The test: would you have bought this item at full price, in the next 30 days, if the sale had not appeared? If no, the “saving” is actually spending.

Buying more than you need because the per-unit price is lower. “Buy 3 get 1 free” on items you only need one of. “Buy Rs 2,000 to get free shipping” when you only needed Rs 800 of product. The Rs 1,200 of additional purchases are not savings. They are spending triggered by pricing architecture.

Shopping as entertainment. The Amazon app and Flipkart app are designed to be browsed. Browsing creates desire. Desire creates purchases. The person who opens these apps as casual entertainment and “just looks around” consistently buys things they did not plan to buy, at prices that feel like deals but represent net outflows from the savings pool.

Seasonal sale psychology. The Big Billion Day, the End of Season Sale, the Republic Day sale. These events create a social environment where not buying feels unusual. The FOMO is social and ambient. The discipline required: have a pre-committed list before entering the sale. Buy only what is on the list, at a price that is genuinely below normal. Nothing else.

The Retirement Arithmetic of Sale Spending

Let me make this concrete. A senior executive earning Rs 3 lakh per month who spends Rs 15,000-20,000 per month on sale-driven unplanned purchases across Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra, and offline sales is consuming Rs 1.8-2.4 lakh per year in avoidable spending.

Rs 15,000 per month redirected to equity SIPs at 12% CAGR for 15 years: approximately Rs 74 lakh of additional retirement corpus.

That is the retirement cost of habitual sale shopping. Not a lecture about frugality. A specific number.

Read – The 50-30-20 Rule: How to Budget Your Way to Retirement Wealth

Read – Your Annual Bonus Is a Retirement Accelerator. Are You Using It Right?

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if a deal is genuinely good?

Three questions: First, was I planning to buy this in the next 30 days before I saw the sale? Second, is this price actually lower than the normal price (check CamelCamelCamel for Amazon price history, or simply remember what the item typically costs)? Third, do I have the cash to pay for this without affecting my monthly savings target? If yes to all three, it is a reasonable purchase. If no to any, it is a sale-triggered impulse buy.

Are loyalty points and cashback worth accumulating?

Cashback and reward points are worth using on planned spending. They are not worth chasing. The person who spends Rs 5,000 extra to earn Rs 100 in points has made a poor trade. The person who earns Rs 500 in annual cashback on insurance premiums and utility bills that they were paying anyway has captured a small, genuine benefit. The discipline is ensuring the tail (points) never wags the dog (spending decisions).

My spouse loves sale shopping and it is creating household tension. What should I do?

This is a family finance conversation, not a shopping conversation. The most productive approach is to agree on a monthly budget for discretionary spending that includes whatever both partners enjoy spending on, without judgment on the category. When the budget is consumed, it is consumed. Neither partner is asking for permission to spend within their agreed allocation, and neither is causing financial harm beyond it. The problem in most households is not that one person shops; it is that spending is not discussed, budgeted, or tracked, so neither person knows whether it is a problem until the savings rate reveals it.

A sale is not money saved. It is an invitation to spend. Whether you save money or spend money depends entirely on whether you would have made that purchase without the sale. That distinction, applied consistently, is worth lakhs in retirement savings over a career.

The best purchase is one you needed. The second best is one you planned. Everything else is the retailer winning.

Want to understand how your spending patterns are affecting your retirement outlook?

RetireWise builds retirement plans that start with your actual cash flows – what goes in, what goes out, and what needs to change.

See Our Retirement Planning Service

💬 Your Turn

Have you ever bought something specifically because it was on sale and later regretted it? What would you have done with that money if the sale had not existed? Share in the comments.

1...303132...51Page 31 of 51